✦ ShadeVault

Best Dupes for Extra super lash (2026)

We found 4 verified dupes for Rimmel Extra super lash, ranked by shade accuracy, formula overlap, and community consensus.

The OriginalRimmel

Extra super lash

$0
FFFA Safe
vs
#1 MatchItalia Deluxe

Perfect Eyeliner Mate Black 2303

$0
CFFFFA Safe
81%Shade
38%Formula
184Mentions

Shop the original

🛒Shop Amazon💄Shop Sephora✨Shop Ulta

Shop the dupe

🛒Shop Amazon💄Shop Sephora✨Shop Ulta
81%Shade Match
38%Formula Similarity
1,392Community Mentions

All 4 Dupes, Ranked

1
Italia Deluxe

Perfect Eyeliner Mate Black 2303

81%Shade
38%Formula
184Mentions
$0View Details
CFFFFA Safe
2
Les Cosmétiques Design Paris

Pro's Great Open Eyes

76%Shade
79%Formula
473Mentions
$0View Details
FFFA Safe
3
Leader Price

Démaquillant Yeux Douceur

57%Shade
50%Formula
257Mentions
$0View Details
FFFA Safe
4
Bourjois

Mascara maxi volume instantané ultra black

54%Shade
43%Formula
478Mentions
$0View Details
FF

Community Verified

These dupes have been discussed across 1,392 Reddit threads and beauty forums. Scores reflect shade match accuracy, ingredient overlap, and real user sentiment.

See Also

Alverde Naturkosmetik

Dupes for Augen Make-Up Entferner

Too Faced Cosmetics

Dupes for Better Than Sex Mascara

Maybelline New York

Dupes for Countdown eyeshadow palette

Léa Nature

Dupes for Crayon yeux tenue intense - 01 noir

Revlon

Dupes for Dramatic Definition 251 Noir Intense

ARTDECO

Dupes for Eyeliner Sensitive Fine Liner